Neil Carmichael - MP for Stroud

Parliamentary speech on the National Planning Policy Framework

24 October 2011 at 12:00

As has been reported, Neil Carmichael is against the developments at Wades Farm and Sellars Farm, on Thursday, 20th October in a debate regarding the National Planning Policy Framework held at the House of Commons Neil gave the following speech.

I draw everyone's attention to my interests as listed in the register.

I am committed to protecting the environment in my constituency. I am committed to ensuring that we have more houses. I think that those two things are quite compatible - they certainly are if we have strong local plans underpinned by proper consultation and the involvement of local people. The Minister was absolutely right when he opened his remarks with the observation that people are worried about having planning done to them rather than being involved in planning. I have noticed that most of the criticisms of the national planning policy framework are along the lines of, "This is going to be terrible for us. Something is going to happen." We have to disabuse people of that fear. I have been doing that to some extent in the constituency already, and this debate has been a useful opportunity to continue that process.

I have listened to Stroud District Council, which is very pleased to find that it will have fewer national guidance documents and more simplified ways of proceeding. It welcomes the idea of having a local plan that will be effectively informed by local opinion. I have also talked to the Gloucestershire Campaign to Protect Rural England. CPRE has been involved nationally, but locally it recognises the importance of a sovereign local plan and wants one in place. We must make sure that it is. The CPRE is also very keen on the idea of the duty to co-operate, as specified in the Localism Bill. That is a really important step, and one that we need to consider.

As far as planning principles go, it is critical to realise that a proper understanding of sustainability is often found at the local level. That is certainly the case in my constituency. That is because factors such as flooding must be included, and local people know about such things. They will be able to put into a local plan a realistic appraisal of the impact of such factors in terms of sustainability. It is right that we make sure that the local plan includes a proper definition of sustainability, and that that has some force and power.

I turn now to the National Trust. It is national; it is not a local structure in the sense of having accountability. Having read the National Trust Act 1971, I cannot find evidence of any accountability at all. However, I agree with some of the points that the trust made to the Environmental Audit Committee, such as those about the definition of sustainability. I tested the Minister on those issues and on issues of local planning, and I am satisfied that the Government have properly thought about the need to link the national planning policy framework with local plans.

There are five things that we really must get right. The first is the transition. There is a lot of concern about the situation that we now find ourselves in, where the NPPF is starting to be referred to as material evidence, and about what might transpire in a planning situation, so we need more clarity about the transition, and also more speed. The second area is the power of local plans. We must be sure that they are the things that matter, and we need to make more noise about that. Certainly we need to talk about the role of the inspectors. In Stroud, the inspectors overturned a decision of the district council, allowing a building development to take place-Foxes Field - which has turned out to be the source of huge trouble. If people had listened more carefully to local opinion, that would have been avoided.

The third area is the capacity of local planners. We have great local planners in Stroud District Council, but we need to make sure that all our councils are properly equipped with the right capacity to make sure that they have a local plan in place, and that that local plan is informed by evidence and reflects local opinion. The fourth area I would like to talk about, which I referred to earlier, is co-operation between councils. Stroud District Council is up against Gloucester, and of course there are issues about where developments take place, so councils need to learn to co-operate. The Government should put more emphasis on that and they should do something if there is no co-operation.

Finally, we need to protect areas of outstanding natural beauty - Harold Wilson's one great achievement - national parks and so on. I am committed to protecting my area, as we have some fantastic places along the Slad valley, and so far we have fought successfully to stop a development on Wades farm. We intend to fight to stop a development on Sellars farm near Hardwicke. We are fighting, first, to protect the AONB and, secondly, to protect the integrity of a village. That is the sort of thing that local people want to do, and they will be able to do it more easily if we have strong and robust local plans.

Tags: Stroud East | Stroud West | North Stroud | Nailsworth and Minchinhampton | Cam and Dursley | Rodborough | Stonehouse | Chalford | | Upton St. Leonards Bisley and Painswick

Posted in Local Business

Neil Carmichael speaking at a City of Westminster event

17 October 2011 at 14:00

Neil Carmichael recently attended an event hosted by the City of Westminster Council in Manchester. Neil in his capacity as a member of the Education Committee at the House of Commons was asked to ... [ read more ]

Tags: North Stroud | Stroud West | Rodborough | Berkeley Vale | Cam and Dursley | Chalford | Nailsworth and Minchinhampton | Upton St Leonards Bisley and Painswick | | Stroud East | Stonehouse

Posted in Events

Autumn and Winter surgery dates now available

15 September 2011 at 10:30

Surgery appointments are now available for reservation for local residents to meet with Neil Carmichael from the end of this month and into February. Neil Carmichael holds a surgery every week at ... [ read more ]

Tags: Stroud East | Stroud West | North Stroud | Nailsworth and Minchinhampton | Cam and Dursley | Chalford | | Rodborough | Stonehouse | Berkeley Vale | Upton St. Leonards Bisley and Painswick

Posted in Events